hm advocate
Scotland’s legal system is unique. Unlike England and Wales, it has its own courts, laws, and prosecutors.
If you’re facing charges for a serious crime in Scotland—or simply want to understand how the system works—you need to know about HM Advocates. They’re the prosecutors who handle high-level criminal cases, and their decisions directly affect outcomes.
This guide explains everything: their role, authority, qualifications, and how they fit into Scottish justice.
What Is an HM Advocate in Scotland?
An HM Advocate (Her Majesty’s Advocate) is a public prosecutor in Scotland. They represent the Crown in serious criminal cases.
Key difference: Scotland doesn’t use the “Crown Prosecution Service” model like England. Instead, it has HM Advocates working within the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS).
In simple terms:
- They decide whether to prosecute serious crimes
- They represent the state in the High Court of Justiciary
- They’re not defence lawyers—they work for the Crown
Where Do HM Advocates Work?
HM Advocates work within the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS)—Scotland’s official prosecution authority.
Here’s the structure:
| Position | Responsibility |
| Lord Advocate | Scotland’s chief law officer (policy & strategy) |
| Solicitor Generals | Senior prosecutors (senior roles) |
| HM Advocates | Serious criminal cases (High Court) |
| Advocate Deputes | Junior prosecutors (less complex cases) |
| Procurator Fiscals | Minor offences (summary cases) |
This hierarchy ensures experienced prosecutors handle the most serious crimes.
What Cases Do HM Advocates Handle?
HM Advocates handle the most serious criminal offences in Scotland. These include:
- Murder and culpable homicide
- Rape and sexual assault
- Fraud and financial crimes
- Drug trafficking
- Armed robbery
- Other indictable offences
All these cases go to the High Court of Justiciary—Scotland’s supreme criminal court.
Why the High Court? These crimes are serious enough to warrant senior judges and formal jury trials.
Key Responsibilities: What HM Advocates Actually Do
Case Assessment
HM Advocates review police evidence and decide: Is there enough evidence to prosecute? Does it meet Scottish criminal law standards?
Indictment Preparation
They draft formal charging documents that list the alleged offences and facts the Crown will prove.
Witness Management
They prepare witnesses for courtroom testimony and ensure evidence is admissible.
Court Presentation
They present the case before a judge and jury, examine witnesses, and argue legal points.
Evidence Handling
They ensure all evidence is properly documented, stored, and presented according to Scottish law.
Legal Research
They research complex legal issues specific to each case.
HM Advocate vs. Lord Advocate: What’s the Difference?
These roles are often confused—but they’re very different.
| HM Advocate | Lord Advocate | |
| Role | Prosecutor (individual cases) | Chief prosecutor (overall strategy) |
| Position | Mid-level | Senior government official |
| Focus | Day-to-day prosecutions | Policy & prosecution direction |
| Authority | Handle specific cases | Oversee the entire prosecution system |
Simple explanation: The Lord Advocate leads; HM Advocates do the prosecuting.
How a Criminal Case Moves Through the System
Here’s the typical timeline when an HM Advocate gets involved:
- Police Investigation Police investigate the crime and gather evidence.
- Referral to HM Advocate. If it’s serious (requiring a High Court trial), the case goes to an HM Advocate.
- Evidence Review: The HM Advocate examines all evidence in detail.
- Decision to Prosecute: If there’s sufficient evidence, they prepare an indictment.
- Indictment Served The formal charges are delivered to the accused.
- High Court Trial The HM Advocate presents the Crown’s case before a judge and jury.
HM Advocate Authority Under Scottish Law
HM Advocates have significant legal power—but it’s limited.
What They CAN Do:
- Prosecute serious crimes in the High Court of Justiciary
- Call and examine witnesses
- Present evidence
- Make prosecutorial decisions based on available evidence
- Withdraw charges if the evidence is insufficient
What They CANNOT Do:
- Ignore Scottish criminal law procedures
- Violate the rights of the accused
- Proceed with weak or inadmissible evidence
- Act outside Crown Office policy guidelines
- Make arbitrary decisions
Important: The Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS) sets prosecution policy. Individual HM Advocates must follow it.
Qualifications: How to Become an HM Advocate
Becoming an HM Advocate requires significant experience:
- Become a Scottish Advocate (law degree + specialist training)
- Practice law for several years (usually 5+ years minimum)
- Pass Crown Office vetting (background checks, legal assessment)
- Demonstrate prosecutorial skills (case experience, legal knowledge)
- Receive Crown Office appointment
It’s a competitive, selective process. Only experienced, qualified lawyers become HM Advocates.
Can an HM Advocate Drop Charges?
Yes, but it’s rare and follows strict procedures.
An HM Advocate can withdraw charges if:
- New evidence emerges that weakens the case
- Original evidence is found to be inadmissible
- They determine there isn’t sufficient evidence to convict
However, this isn’t done casually. There are review processes and accountability mechanisms in place.
Advocate Deputes: Junior Prosecutors
Advocate Deputes are essentially junior HM Advocates. They’re experienced advocates who handle:
- Less complex cases
- Cases supervised by senior HM Advocates
- Some prosecution work when senior prosecutors are busy
This system brings talented private practitioners into the prosecution service, improving flexibility and quality.
What’s the Difference Between COPFS and Police?
Many people confuse these roles:
| Police | COPFS (HM Advocates) | |
| Job | Investigate crimes, gather evidence | Decide whether to prosecute |
| Authority | Make arrests, search, interview | Present the case in court |
| Decision | “Did they commit the crime?” | “Should we prosecute based on evidence?” |
Key point: Police investigate; prosecutors decide whether to charge and prosecute.
How Long Do Criminal Cases Take?
The answer: It varies widely.
- Simple cases: 3–6 months
- Standard cases: 6–18 months
- Complex cases: 18 months to 3+ years
Complexity, number of witnesses, and legal issues all affect timeline.
Scottish law protects defendants: There are strict timelines and procedural rules that speed up the process and prevent indefinite delays.
What If You Disagree With a Prosecution Decision?
If an HM Advocate decides not to prosecute, you have options:
- COPFS Review – Request the Crown Office review the decision
- Judicial Review – In limited circumstances, decide to decide – File a formal complaint with COPFS
However, the Crown retains significant discretion in prosecution decisions.
FAQs: Common Questions About HM Advocates
How much do HM Advocates earn?
Salaries vary, but senior HM Advocates earn competitive government salaries (roughly £70,000–£120,000+, depending on experience and seniority).
Can an HM Advocate be challenged in court?
Yes. If an HM Advocate makes procedural errors, the defence can challenge their actions in court. Judges oversee their conduct.
Are HM Advocates overworked?
Large cases can be extremely demanding, requiring months of preparation and evidence review.
How many HM Advocates are there in Scotland?
The exact number varies, but there are dozens across different regions (Edinburgh, Glasgow, Aberdeen, etc.).
What happens if an HM Advocate is dishonest?
Scottish legal professional bodies can investigate and discipline or remove prosecutors who breach ethical standards.
Key Takeaways: Understanding HM Advocates in Scotland
- HM Advocates are serious crime prosecutors – They handle murder, rape, fraud, and other major offences in Scotland’s High Court of Justiciary.
- They work within COPFS – The Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service is the prosecution authority; HM Advocates are the experienced prosecutors who work there.
- They have real power—but it’s limited – They decide whether to prosecute, but must follow Scottish law, COPFS policy, and professional ethics.
- Experience is required – Only qualified, vetted advocates become HM Advocates after years of legal practice.
- The system balances power with accountability – Rigorous procedures, court oversight, and professional standards keep prosecutors fair and effective.
- Scotland’s system is unique – Unlike England and Wales, Scotland has its own prosecutors, courts, and laws.
Final Thoughts
If you’re involved in a serious criminal matter in Scotland, understanding HM Advocates helps you understand the prosecution process. These are highly skilled lawyers with significant responsibility—and that responsibility is taken seriously.
The Scottish prosecution system depends on HM Advocates to handle the most serious crimes fairly, rigorously, and in line with the law. It’s a system designed to protect both the public and the rights of the accused.
Links:-
About the Author
